Search This Blog

Wednesday, 18 May 2016

World History: Ancient Greece

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Greece
Last time on World History we covered the Achaemenids of Persia (http://historyandgeekstuff.blogspot.co.uk/2016/03/world-history-achaemenid-empire.html). This week we shall focus on the ancient society that managed to repel them: the Greeks. Ancient Greece has greatly influenced the western world and people all across the world flock to see the ruins that they left behind. Everyone knows the names of Sparta and Athens, Aristotle and Sophocles, Homer and Herodotus. However, how much of this compares to the actual Greece of ancient times? This World History post shall cover Greece from the early Iron Age right up to Rome's conquering of Greece in 146 BCE.

Ancient Greek Periods
For the time that we are covering in this post there are three periods that we will be looking at: the Archaic Period, the Classic Period and the Hellenistic Period. Centuries before the rise of the Greece that is often portrayed in the media there was a 'Dark Age' following the collapse of the Mycenaeans on mainland Greece. Following this period of time iron became widely adopted and new societies started to develop. The Archaic Period starts in 776 BCE when traditional Greek historians say that the first Olympic games were held. The Archaic Period lasts until 480 BCE with the attempted Persian invasion of mainland Greece. This saw the famous Battle of Thermopylae with Leonidas and his 300 Spartans facing off against the Persian army of Xerxes, (although the reality is far from what is portrayed in the media). The Classical Period then starts. This period also will see the rise of Alexander the Great. The Classical Period ends in 323 BCE with the death of Alexander and the fragmentation of his empire. Finally, we have the Hellenistic Period which lasts until Roman conquest of Greece in 146 BCE. 

Greek State Organization
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Greece
 Ancient Greece was very much like many other ancient societies located along the Mediterranean and Near East. However, despite what many people today Greek politics and society were very much different from today's societies. The landscape of Greece meant that forming an even feudal society exceedingly difficult. Greece is divided by seas, valleys and mountains which made communication between communities difficult. Also, the landscape reduced the amount of arable land which could be found compared to that of the Near East. Greek societies in the Archaic Period formed city-states called polis. The polis would rule over land outside of the city where farmers would grow crops and raise cattle, or people would mine metals, in order to sell to the city. During the Archaic Period inter-polis trade occurred and the larger ones would often dominate the smaller ones. However, there was not enough arable land in Greece to sustain a large population. The Greeks formed colonies across the Mediterranean where they would often trade with either the local peoples or the other major Mediterranean power, the Phoenicians. The Greek colonies became heavily invested in trade and had a great influence on the local areas. The Etruscans of northern Italy, for example, started depicting chimeras of Greek mythology in their art and built temples resembling Greek ones. However, the colonies were not like the colonies of the European empires. The colonies were more or less their own independent polis with some ties to their parent polis. For example, Thracian colonies would ally themselves with Thrace. However, there was no direct commitment towards each other. 

Trade caused the rise of a middle class during the Archaic Period. The famous Greek hoplites and the phalanx was made of predominantly middle class citizens of each polis. Eventually the polis created tyrannos or 'tyrants' to rule them through either the middle classes supporting an opportunistic aristocrat or, by appointing a 'lawgiver' to mediate disputes between the classes. In Athens for half of the sixth-century the Peisistratid dynasty produced tyrant after tyrant. Before them there was Draco who ruled Athens around 620 BCE. He abolished the old blood feuds and oral laws in favor of a written code which would be enforced by the courts. This law code was extremely strict bringing in place the death penalty for many laws but his constitution and laws would pave the way for Athenian democracy in the 5th century BCE. Despite the various forms of government which would arise in the Classical Period and the regional disparities across Greece the polis were (mostly) culturally united. They all spoke the same language, used the same script, worshiped the same gods and they were willing to unite forces against the invading Persians. The Olympics were held every four years at Olympia where the Greek states would cease fighting in favor of honoring Zeus and non-violently competing against one another. Also, they showed signs of xenophobia. Only Greeks (and even then Greek men) could compete in the Olympics and anyone who could not speak Greek were seen as barbarians (the word is Greek in origin as they thought all other languages sounded like they were saying 'bar-bar').

Religion and Spirituality
http://www.greece.com/info/culture/ancient_greek_religion/
Ancient Greek religion most likely originated with the Mycenaeans who proceeded them during the Bronze Age. The ancient Greeks were polytheistic (having multiple gods) with a clearly defined hierarchy. At the top was Zeus, the god of the sky and of the gods, who ruled from Mount Olympus. The Greeks had many gods ranging from Hades, god of the Underworld, to Aphrodite, goddess of love. The Greek gods, however, believed that the gods were like humans in the fact that they would succumb to vices and their emotions. Zeus often turned into animals to abduct and rape women, through this the Minotaur of Greek mythology was born, and Hades abducted Persephone, the daughter of the goddess Demeter, after instantly falling in love with her. Greek ideas of death are far removed from the modern day ideas of death. For one, the correct death ritual had to be undertaken in order to allow the soul to pass on to the other side as otherwise it would haunt the mortal world. Two coins were placed over the eyes and the corpse buried with food, the coins to pay Charon who guides the dead to the afterlife and the food to feed Cerberus, the three headed dog who guards the Underworld. The Underworld is ruled by Hades, who is not an evil figure in ancient Greek religion, who resides in the 'land of Hades'. The Underworld then has two other layers: Tartarus, for the damned, and Elysium, for the virtuous. Appeasing the gods was seen as essential and to do this a sacrifice of a domestic animal was done in a temple. Roman religion would be greatly inspired by that of Greece with many gods being incorporated into the Roman pantheon of gods.

Social Organization
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_ancient_Greece
The polis was an oligarchy, a government run by a few people, where either aristocrats or a wealthy elite ruled. It was these men, women were not allowed, who decided laws for each polis. In fact the word politics derives from polis. After 510 BCE, however, Athens managed to oust the ruling tyrants and establish a direct democracy. This form of rule saw men, (again women were excluded), meet up to form the ecclesia where they would vote on laws. At the time it was the most democratic institution in Greece. This was especially true compared to Athen's major opponent of Sparta. Sparta never had the tyrants of Athens and instead retained an aristocratic oligarchy of a council of old men, five magistrates called 'ephors' and two hereditary kings with special military powers. While Athens was a mercantile state Sparta was an agricultural one. While the rest of Greece by 600 BCE had coins Sparta retained its iron currency until the 4th century BCE. While Athenian armies were socially stratified Spartan armies were egalitarian with all soldiers living together, eating together and wearing the same clothing regardless of wealth. Sparta relied heavily on the army where even during a wedding ceremony the prospective wife would be made to look like a man (only men could be Spartan soldiers) and the husband would go live with his fellow soldiers after the wedding. Although united by religion and language Greece was divided in many other ways.

The position of women varied in each society. Universally they were excluded from politics, had to rely on their fathers if they wanted a divorce and in Athens were not regarded as citizens. However, Spartan women held more power managing to run and own property during times of war, something which was a common occurrence for Sparta. Although women could have indirect power if wealthy by influencing their husbands. Slavery was a common occurrence in Greece. Athens had an extremely high slave population (one in four of the population) and Homer noted that often women were enslaved during war. Although unlike Rome large slave plantations were unusual. Often slaves were household slaves with a freeman owning up to two slaves. Unlike the slavery which arose thanks to the European powers centuries later Greek slaves could be treated kindly and even loved. Aesop of Aesop's Fables was one such slave. They could easily be freed and given a good life with one slave in the 4th century BCE becoming a banker. However, just because some slaves were given a good life that did not mean every slave was treated like this. Athenian household slaves had some rights whereas Laureion mining slaves and prostitutes were treated brutally. Also there was no abolitionism in Greece. Aristotle for one said that some people were slaves by nature so should not be freed.

Ideas and Inventions
Aristotle: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristotle
Ancient Greece is in a fierce battle with Mesopotamia for the civilization which has the greatest impact on the western world. Science, maths, philosophy and history all owe themselves to the ancient Greeks. Herodotus, for example, is often regarded as the first historian writing The History of the Greco-Persian War in 449 BCE and Thucydides's History of the Peloponnesian War is still read today. Pythagoras is taught in every school across the world for his triangular theory and Euclid's geometry was taught all the way up until the early 20th century in European schools. Archimedes (287-212 BCE) greatly influenced maths with his work to find the area of a circle, surface area and volume of a sphere, approximation of pi and the area under a parabola. Aristotle's theories of the sun and classification of life would influence science for generations to come. Philosophy saw great progresses thanks to the ancient Greeks. Stoicism, for one, was developed thanks to Socrates and Plato as well as countless other philosophies. 

Greco-Persian and Peloponnesian Wars
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Thermopylae
Greece saw several wars which ravaged the land but we'll look at two. The first is the Greco-Persian War where people have claimed that if the Persians had won democracy would have been choked in its cradle. The war broke out when Greek states started to support Greek Ionian cities revolting under the rule of Achaemenid Darius the Great as they did not like the tyrants he had put in place. Wanting to crush the Greeks in 492 BCE Darius sent his son-in-law Mardonius to subjugate Thrace and told the Greek states to surrender. Athens and Sparta refused to so Darius invaded Greece. In 490 BCE a Persian force landed at Marathon, roughly 25 miles from Athens, but were defeated. The marathon race is named after this as messengers had to run to Athens to warn them of the invasion. Darius decided to regroup and in 480 BCE his son, Xerxes, decided to finish what his father started. That year saw the famous Battle of Thermopylae which had more than 300 Spartans fighting less than one million Persians (Herodotus liked to exaggerate). However, it would take until 449 BCE for the war to end. After this would democracy have died if Persia had won? I believe not. Democracy has always appeared throughout history, while France had an autocratic king the Xhosa of South Africa had a direct democracy, and if it died in Athens it would have returned somewhere else. In fact Athenian democracy had been removed then reestablished several times. Also the Persians styled themselves as 'king of kings'. This meant they would rule through a leader. Possibly a democracy could have survived although under the thumb of Xerxes instead.

The second war I wish to discuss is the Peloponnesian War. This war broke out in 431 BCE and lasted until 404 BCE where the Delian League, led by Athens, fought the Peloponnesian League, led by Sparta. When Persia was expelled Athens and Sparta became dominant powers in Greece. This brought tensions and war broke out. Sparta and its allies were largely a land power whereas Athens was a sea power. Eventually Sparta and its allies won, the Delian League was dissolved and Sparta ended Athenian democracy replacing it with 'Thirty Tyrants'. As a rebuttal of the idea that Persia would have ended democracy Sparta removed Athenian democracy but it survives today. In fact Athens regained democracy a few years just a year after the 'Thirty Tyrants' were imposed. The war weakened the Greek states so much that Philip II of Macedon would later easily conquer all of Greece, bar Sparta. His message to Sparta saying 'If I invade Laconia you will be destroyed, never to rise again.' the Spartans replied with 'If'

In the end Greece succumbed to the Roman empire. However, there is one figure in history who ruled Greece (bar Sparta), ended the Achaemenid Empire, conquered Egypt and is referred to as 'Great'. The next World History we shall see if this figure deserves such as title and whether it is a good thing to look at history through the lives of individuals. Next time we'll look at Alexander the Great. Thanks for reading and the sources which I have used are as follows:
-The Penguin History of the World by J.M. Roberts
-The Complete Archaeology of Greece: From Hunter-Gatherers to the 20th Century A.D. by John Bintliff
-History of the Peloponnesian War by Thucydides
-https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q-mkVSasZIM

For a list of other World History posts please see here

Saturday, 7 May 2016

Review: Captain America: Civil War (2016)

Warning: Contains Spoilers!
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt3498820/
The new entry in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) has been released to much critical acclaim. This review will contain spoilers so to see my final verdict/thoughts please skip to the conclusion. 

Acting 
https://castofmovies.com/movies/captain-america-civil-war-2016/
Without a doubt this is one of the best acted films in the MCU. This comes from both the already established cast and the new cast. Chris Evans as Captain America is superb once again as well as his co-stars with Scarlett Johansson, (Black Widow), Robert Downy Jr (Iron Man), Don Cheadle (War Machine) and, Anthony Mackie (Falcon). Evans and Downy Jr have been playing their characters for years now and now they perfect for their roles. Compared to Captain America: The First Avenger Evans as the titular character is perfect. Sebastian Stan as Bucky Barnes/The Winter Soldier is surprisingly good as well. He very much gives off the appearance of someone broken and struggling to regain his lost life. Elizabeth Olsen is far better in this film than she was in Avengers 2. In the last film her attempt at a vague eastern European accent was very off-putting. In contrast, her performance in this film is far better. The accent is far more toned down and she placed acting over fake accent. The accent is still there but it is not distracting as it was last time. This film brought two new heroes into the MCU: Spider-Man (played by Tom Holland) and Black Panther (played by Chadwick Boseman). Boseman is incredible. Black Panther is my favorite Marvel hero and I was worried in case the Black Panther that I love would be misrepresented in the film. The exact opposite happened. Boseman portrayed the Black Panther flawlessly, he portrayed someone wanting revenge so much that it was consuming him and, this was with an accent. His accent seemed to be natural and suited his role perfectly. If anything it added to the acting. Tom Holland is really good as Spider-Man. I would say he is the best live action Spider-Man so far. He puts across really well the cheeky, little punk early Spider-Man really well and his work alongside already established actors like Evans and Downy Jr added to this. The only criticism in regards to acting is due to Martin Freeman as Everett Ross. The acting is let down by this American accent. While Boseman's accent added to his role Freeman's accent took everything away from it. If he didn't have that accent it would have been good performance.

Plot and Characters
Following civilian casualties during an Avengers mission in Lagos on top of damages during the Avengers, Captain America: Winter Soldier and Avengers 2 the UN proposes to place the Avengers under its control. This splits the Avengers and following Bucky supposedly bombing a UN Summit in Vienna Captain America vows to protect his friend. However, battlelines are drawn as Captain America, Falcon, Scarlet Witch (Olsen), Bucky, Ant-Man (Paul Rudd) and Hawkeye (Jeremy Renner) clash against Iron Man, War Machine, Black Panther, Black Widow, Spider-Man and Vision (Paul Bettany). All the while someone called Zemo (Daniel Bruhl) is plotting in the background. The plot is very good. It is very well paced so the two hour twenty minute runtime just flies by. The fight scenes are well choreographed and are very engaging. The airport fight scene is now perhaps one of my favorite moments in the MCU. Due to the amount of characters and story arcs I was worried that it would all feel shoehorned in but the Russo brothers did a very good job in avoiding this. I must also give them credit for actually adapting the Civil War storyline and doing it well. Civil War spanned almost the entire Marvel Universe and many influential characters in the story, (like the Fantastic Four, Namor and Wolverine), are not owned by Marvel Entertainment. They did a good job of making it fit into the MCU as well as making Captain America the center of the film. They managed to create a film which spans most of the MCU which also keeps the focus of whose film it actually is.

The characters are also well written. Black Panther hating Bucky until the end is highly justified and is portrayed in a realistic manner. Captain America's support for Bucky is highly justified as well and Iron Man's support for the UN proposal. The relationship between Vision and Scarlet Witch feels natural, the friendship of Black Widow and Captain America (and Hawkeye) feels natural, Iron Man and Captain America regretting feels natural. I love also how Ant-Man reacts in awe of Captain America. In the MCU he would be a massive figure so Ant-Man reacting the way he does actually feels natural. It is done for laughs but in real life that would likely be a realistic response. Spider-Man's reactions with other heroes is very well done. They perfectly captured who Spider-Man as a character is. Even the villain, Zemo, is done very well. At first I thought he would be another throwaway villain like all other MCU villains bar Loki. Instead he was a good villain. His goal to break up the Avengers because his family were indirectly killed by them in Avengers 2 is realistic for a man of his background. The fact that you actually feel pity for him as well when it is revealed that the message he keeps listening to is the last message his wife sent to him adds so much to the character. This is the film that I wish Batman v Superman was. It has the same message of controlling power, the same hero v. hero dilemma and the same motive of the villain wanting a hero to fall. Here though the reason they fight, (even the last fight of Iron Man v. Bucky and Captain America), actually is a reason, enough time is allotted to both characters and, the villain actually makes sense instead of Lex Luthor's eccentric garbled mess of a plan which still does not make sense.

Effects
http://www.hitfix.com/harpy/so-we-need-to-talk-about-spider-mans-costume-in-the-captain-america-civil-war-trailer
Like other entries in the MCU the effects are still very good. It's a small thing but one scene shows a young Tony Stark and it looks very good. I like also the blend of live action and CGI. I was worried that most of the film would be just one giant CGI blast like Jurassic World or Man of Steel. Instead they actually used a mix of both techniques. It added much to the film. I am very glad that movies are now more willing to blend practical effects and CGI together (I am hopeful that Warcraft will have good effects judging by how they are doing this). During the airport fight scene at times I did struggle to guess which parts were CGI and which were practical effects. However, at times the CGI does look somewhat fake, incidentally the airport fight in my opinion has some of the best and worst effects in the movie, which can be off-putting. However, this is rare and I would rather have a film with some effect mishaps than an entire CGI blast to the face. 

Trivia and Easter Eggs
http://www.cinemablend.com/images/news/117737/_1457647154.jpg
Like other MCU entries there are multiple references to the comics. The above image actually appears in one of the comics. In Avengers #224 Ant-Man rides Hawkeye's arrows as he does in the film which is really nice. Vision and Scarlet Witch appear to have a growing bond between the two of them throughout the film. In the comics they started a relationship and got married, which ended up going spectacularly wrong as what always seems to happen in comics. Falcon, also, uses a drone called Redwing in the film. In the comics Falcon has an actual falcon called Redwing. Iron Man is also influenced to support hero's working for a government by a mother whose son who was indirectly killed by heroes. In the film her son was a volunteer who was killed by falling buildings in Sokovia while in the comics the son is in elementary school and is killed by the villain Nitro's blast while fighting a teenage hero group called the New Warriors. (I've done a Comics Explained on Civil War of you want more details: http://historyandgeekstuff.blogspot.co.uk/2015/02/comics-explained-marvel-civil-war.html). Bucky also loses his arm in the same tradition of MCU films since Phase Two where a character loses an arm/hand in homage to Empire Strikes Back (also mentioned by Spider-Man in the film). Spider-Man's costume is also a mixture of two of his most famous costumes: one by Steve Ditko and one by John Romita Sr. Iron Man also makes Spider-Man his suit while in Civil War he makes Spider-Man a new suit. The two credit scenes both set up the upcoming Black Panther and Spider-Man: Homecoming set to be released in 2017 and 2018. Finally during Captain America's and Iron Man's final fight one shot directly homages the cover of the last issue of Civil War.
http://nerdist.com/movie-morsels-captain-america-civil-wars-controversial-ending/
Conclusion
Captain America: Civil War is a must see for comic book fans and comic book movie fans alike. With overall good acting, good pacing, well written characters, good effects and spectacular fight scenes it is a must see. I would give Civil War a 8.5/10 for these reasons. If you have seen it go see it again, if you haven't seen it go see it and if you've not seen any MCU films watch Iron Man, Captain America: The First Avenger, Avengers, Captain America: Winter Solider and Avengers 2 and then see this one.

Friday, 29 April 2016

A History of Ice and Fire: Aegon's Conquest

http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Balerion
War has ravaged the lands of Westeros over the last few years. The War of the Five Kings had caused a wave of destruction and a countless loss of life from Winterfell to Dorne. To the north of the Wall Wildlings have made bloody battle against the Night's Watch and, apparently, there are rumors that the dead has started to walk the land. Meanwhile in Slaver's Bay Daenerys Targaryen has caused a war in her attempt to free the slaves that they hold. However, centuries ago war ravaged Westeros and a kingdom was forged through blood, steel and dragon flame. This was the kingdom of Aegon Targaryen, (the ancestor of Daenerys Targaryen), and this is how he conquered Westeros with two sisters and three dragons.

Before the Conquest
http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Doom_of_Valyria
Centuries ago the Valyrians held a great empire which encompassed much of Essos and even stretched as far as Dragonstone, an island only a few miles off the coast of Westeros. It was an empire forged with dragon fire and the will of their Valyrian masters. However, this all changed during the Doom of Valyria where a great cataclysm, still unknown to this day, destroyed Valyria. Valyrian colonies across Essos became free cities, the dragons were almost wiped out and the last Valyrian noble family, Targaryen, remained on Dragonstone. Around 112 years later Aegon Targaryen, Rhaenys Targaryen and Visenya Targaryen were tied between heading east to reconquer and reunify the former Valyrian cities or head west and begin the difficult task of conquering Westeros. Although they had a small navy and army they had the advantage of three fully grown dragons: Vhagar, Meraxes and the largest of the three Balerion the Black Dread. In preparation Aegon had a painted table made of Westeros showing no borders, this was an indication that he wished to conquer all of Westeros. The king of the Stormlands, Argilic the Arrogant, offered to marry his daughter to Aegon but Aegon refused deciding to carry on the Valyrian tradition of marrying siblings, to keep the bloodline 'pure', and married both Visenya and Rhaenys. He did offer the hand of his close friend, and possible brother, Orys Baratheon but an enraged Argilac cut the hands off of Aegon's messenger saying 'These are the only hands you will receive'. Aegon sent ravens to each kingdom calling them to yield to him. None did. Thus Aegon, Rhaenys and Visenya in 2 BC (Before Conquest) landed on Westeros.

The Landing
It was likely that Aegon had been to Westeros before despite what maesters used to claim. With fewer than 1,600 men the king and queens started the construction of Aegonfort where they would plan their future conquests. House Velaryon, (who were also Valyrian), aided them and soon houses Celtigar and Massey joined the Targaryens. Rhaenys quickly subdued House Rosby while Visenya subdued House Stokeworth. Lord Darklyn of Duskendale and Lord Mooton though gave the Targaryens their first challenge when they pulled resources and marched south. Orys Baratheon led a land assault against them while Aegon rising Balerion set upon them from above. both lords perished in dragon fire and their heirs quickly surrendered to Aegon. However, the Targaryens saw a setback when the navy under Daemon Velaryon was destroyed, (and Daemon killed), by a hastily assembled Arryn of the Vale fleet. Visenya riding Vhagar quickly burned the Arryn fleet which caused the Three Sisters (three islands off the coast of the Vale) to declare independence.

Burning of Harrenhal
http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Aegon's_Conquest
It would be Harren Hoare, the King of the Isles and the Rivers, that would give the Targaryens their first major conquest. Harren Hoare controlled vast amounts of land and ruled over a large chunk of Westeros. His expansionism had caused Argilac the Arrogant to offer Aegon the hand of his daughter as a defensive maneuver. The brutality of Harren Hoare was well renowned for his brutality and he had forsaken the modest home of his father for a much grander home. By the time of Aegon's conquest it had been completed: Harrenhal. It was a virtually impenetrable castle. Harrenhal was built close to the Gods Eye which served Hoare well, House Hoare could utilize their impressive longboats this way. Although initially defeated at the Battle of the Reeds they dealt extensive damage to Aegon's troops at the Wailing Willows. Two of Harren's sons using muffled oars had managed to sneak up to Aegon's troops and then a massacre started. However, Balerion soon burnt the longboats and Harren lost his two sons. Following this Harren summoned the River lords to defend him but under Edmyn Tully of Riverrun they refused to do so and joined Aegon. Afraid Harren held up in Harrenhal. When Aegon arrived Harren refused to exit saying that 'Stone does not burn'. Harren underestimated the power of dragonflame. Stone may not burn but it did crumble under the intense heat of Balerion's breath. Flammable materials like straw took alight and soon the line of Harren Hoare was disintegrated. Today Harrenhal is supposedly the most haunted castle in Westeros and rumors say that it is still possible to hear the screams of Harren and his sons as they burnt to death. For his loyalty Edmyn Tully was made Lord Paramount of the Trident. Aegon would later invade the Iron Islands (the Islands in Harren Hoare's title) and make the ironborn bend the knee. Lord Vickon Greyjoy was then made Lord of the Iron Islands and a vassel to the Targaryens.

Conquest of the Stormlands
https://throneslife.com/characters/house-baratheon/
Next to fall would be the Storm King Argilac the Arrogant. As Aegon was battling House Hoare his sister Rhaenys riding Meraxes and Orys Baratheon went to conquer the Stormlands. So eager was Argilac to defend himself from the Targaryens that he had all his vassels meet him at Storm's End while allowing pirates and the Dornish to raid part of his land. While the Targaryens crossed the Wendwater a bannerman of Argilac, Lord Errol, set upon them and managed to kill a thousand Targaryen soldiers. However, Rhaenys retaliated by having Meraxes burn the forests where the attackers were hiding in resulting in Errol burning to death. Eager not to result in more loss of life the Targaryen forces bunkered down at Bronzegate to wait for Argilac who had left his castle after hearing what happened to Harren Hoare. The next battle was named the Last Storm. Argilac's forces crashed against the Targaryens. Argilac thought he had victory when he managed to break through Orys's center until he came face to face with Rhaenys rising Meraxes. His personal guard perished in dragonfire and he was thrown from the saddle. He refused to yield and in single combat Orys killed Argilac. They then went to Storm's End. Argilac's daughter, Argella, sealed the gate and was willing to share the same fate as Harren Hoare. Her soldiers were not and handed her over to the Rhaenys and Orys. Orys ended up marrying her and he adopted her family's motto (Ours is the fury) and sigil (a stag on a yellow background) for House Baratheon. Orys was soon made Lord Paramount of the Stormlands. Meanwhile at Crackclaw Point Visenya subdued the local lords with no fight who became direct vassels of the king.

The Field of Fire
http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/Field_of_Fire
Seeing two of the major kingdoms conquered, arguably, two most powerful kings, King Mern IX Gardener of the Reach and King Loren Lannister of he Rock, made common cause. They assembled an army of 55,000, where 5000 were knights, and marched to defeat the dragon king and queens. Aegon, Rhaenys and Visenya met up from their various conquests and went to battle against the two kingdoms. Mern Gardener led the center of the giant army while his vassel House Oakheart led the left while Loren Lannister led the right. At first it seemed the Targaryens would lose the battle. They were heavily outnumbered and the knights had penetrated the Targaryen army. This all changed when the Targaryens riding their three dragons descended onto the field. Spewing fire they cooked the opposing army. It was a massacre. In the end five thousand were burned alive and a further ten thousand were injured it what has been called the Field of Fire. Among the dead were Mern Gardener and all of his kin. The Gardeners had perished in dragonfire. Loren Lannister yielded the next day and Aegon allowed him to become Warden of the West. The Gardener steward, Harlen Tyrell, surrendered the capital castle of Highgardern and was made Lord Paramount of the Mander, a position that the Tyrells have today. However, they could not celebrate. The North had joined the war.

The North, Vale and Dorne
http://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Aegon's_Conquest
Aegon was initially to conquer the south but the King of the North Torrhen Stark had crossed the Neck with an army of 30,000. Aegon summoned all of those who had yielded and by the time Torrhen Stark had reached the Trident Aegon had an army consisting of men from the Reach, westerlands, riverlands and stormlands and, the army was twice the size of Stark's. Naturally Stark was not eager to replicated the Field of Fire with his northmen. Some lords suggested he retreat to Moat Cailin and fortify it while his illegitimate half-brother, Brandon Snow, offered a more secretive and daring plan. Brandon wanted to sneak into the Targaryen camp during the night and slay the dragons. However, Torrhen knew that the plan would fail and chose to negotiate a surrender. Earning him centuries later the mocking title the King-Who-Knelt Torrhen Stark became Warden of the North. However, doing this spared the lives, and the power, of the North. While this was happening Sharra Arryn, Queen regent of the Vale, fortified her cities and held herself up in the mountain fortress of the Eyrie with her son. For an invading army to conquer the Eyrie it would mean battling through three heavily fortified gates, up a mountain and brave high winds while being fired upon. Arryn felt safe that the Targaryens could not get her. That is until Visenya landed in the courtyard with her dragon. She let the young king Ronnel Arryn fly on the dragon as Visenya and Sharra discussed the Vale's surrender. By the time he landed he was no longer King of the Vale. Rhaenys had less look subjugating Dorne. She flew castle to castle on her dragon only to find them empty. She could not be secure conquering Dorne if no one surrendered to her. Finally at the capital of Sunspear she met the Princess of Dorne, the aging Meria Martell. Much of the Dornish nobility are descended from Princess Nymeria from Rhoynar so they use the Rhoynish terminology of 'Prince' and 'Princess' over the Westerosi 'King' and 'Queen'. Princess Meria Martell simply told Rhaenys that Dorne had no king and that 'Your words, Ours are Unbowed, Unbent, Unbroken. You may burn us, my lady, but you will not bend us, break us, or make us bow. This is Dorne. You are not wanted here. Return at your peril.' She did that and Dorne remained independent.

The Last Conquests
Only Oldtown and the Iron Islands remained. Oldtown was important as it was where the maesters were trained and where the High Septon, the leader of the Faith of the Seven, sat. Capturing it would remove the last obstacle to Aegon's unchallenged rule. The High Septon prayed for seven days and nights until supposedly he was visited by the Crone who told him to surrender. The High Septon told the leader of Gulltown, Lord Manfred Hightower, he decided not to follow his master King Mern Gardener into battle. Lord Hightower immediately welcomed Aegon to Oldtown when he arrived and the High Septon crowned him Aegon of House Targaryen, First of His Name, King of the Andals, the Rhoynar, and the First Men, Lord of the Seven Kingdoms and Protector of the Realm. Although this was inaccurate as Dorne was still free and the Iron Islands were still free but in disarray. A year after he was crowned he invaded the Iron Islands (explained above). His kingdom was complete.

Aftermath
During his reign Aegon would create a more centralized kingdom but he would crave Dorne. From 4 to 13 AC (After Conquest) he would lead an invasion of Dorne and true to her words Meria Martell remain Unbowed, Unbent and Unbroken. Rhaenys and her dragon Meraxes were both killed in the war which resulted in Aegon going into a stupor for years. Dorne would not be permanently incorporated into the kingdom until 187 AC via marriage and not conquest. Dorne remains out of all the kingdoms to have the most sovereignty, other than possibly the North. Aegonfort was eventually expanded to become an actual keep and is now known as the Red Fort surrounded by Westeros's capital King's Landing. Aegon knew though that a monarch could not be complacent. He had the swords of all those he surrendered gathered together and forged together to form a throne. That throne is the same throne that has been contested by so many over the years: the Iron Throne.
http://gameofthrones.wikia.com/wiki/Iron_Throne

Sunday, 24 April 2016

History in Focus: The Easter Rising

http://www.easter1916.net/
As of writing it is the centenary of the start of the Easter Uprising. From April 24 to April 29 1916 in Dublin, (and a few minor skirmishes in Meath, Wexford, Louth and Galway), Irish nationals rose up. Although the leaders of the uprising knew full well that they would fail they decided to martyr themselves for the cause of Irish independence. The Easter Uprising had a massive impact on not just Irish history but the history of the British Isles. Over the last hundred years the memory of the Uprising has ingrained itself in culture; the band The Cranberries in their song Zombie make reference to the event with the line 'it's the same old team since 1916'. Today we shall look at the Easter Uprising and see why it is so important.

Background
http://punch.photoshelter.com/gallery/Ireland-Cartoons/G0000tcWkXyP4OHo/
Since 1169 Ireland had been in some way or another a possession of England and, following 1603, Scotland. In 1800 though the Act of Union forming the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland ,(union between England and Scotland forming Britain happened in 1707), was passed. This dissolved the Irish Parliament and Irish MPs went to sit in the Westminster government. However, Ireland was a subordinate partner in the Union and, many social, economic and political grievances took years to be addressed if they were addressed at all. Starting in the 1840s movements calling for the repeal of the Union started to grow which became far more popular in 1846. A fungus named phytophthora wiped out three quarters of the potato crop which was a staple in the diet of the poor Irish. The lack of response from Britain caused one million to starve and a further 1.5 million to leave the country. It was so bad that Ireland's population has still yet to recover. Grievances over Union membership and land ownership caused various groups to become a driving force in politics. In 1848 there was even a small uprising by a nationalist group called the Young Irishmen. In the 1850s a group called the Fenians started a campaign of terror which spread to the mainland. The British government started mixing coercion and conciliation to stop the Fenians. For example, they passed in 1871 a Coercion Bill giving Irish police special powers to arrest people while in 1869 they passed the Irish Church Act which ended the dominance of the Anglican Church in Ireland, (80% of the Irish population was Roman Catholic). However, the idea of Home Rule was wanted. Home Rule in Ireland would have resurrected an Irish Parliament which would be able to decide anything bar defense and foreign affairs which would remain in Westminster's hands. In 1874 the Irish Parliamentary Party would be founded by Isaac Butt to achieve this but it would be under the tutelage of Charles Stewart Parnell it would become a major party holding the balance of power in Britain. In the 1885 elections he managed to get 86 seats in Parliament despite being imprisoned only four years prior. In 1886 Liberal Prime Minister William Gladstone tried to have Home Rule passed but was defeated. 

Following the Bill's defeat Parnell's image was tainted and, Home Rule was set back when the Liberal party split between those opposing and supporting it. In 1891 Parnell died and his successor John Redmond continued the cause. However, by the 1890s there was a divide in Ireland. In the largely Catholic south there was a revival in Gaelic and Irish culture with the Gaelic Athletic Association and Gaelic League becoming popular. In the province of Ulster (modern day Northern Ireland) with a largely Protestant population the Gaelic revival and Home Rule was opposed. Some opposed it as a Home Rule Parliament would be located in Dublin and they feared a 'Rome Rule' while others would only support it if the Parliament was located in Ulster as they saw themselves superior to the Catholic Irish. Those who opposed Home Rule became known as Unionists and consisted of figures including future Prime Minister Andrew Bonar Law and Joseph Chamberlain (the father of Neville Chamberlain who used Appeasement against Hitler). In 1906 the Conservatives (largely Unionist) were defeated by Asquith's Liberals (largely in favor of Home Rule) who soon allied the Liberals with Redmond's Irish Party. Irish society then became militarized. In 1912 riots broke out in Belfast opposing Home Rule and in the south a militant group named the Volunteers were formed. Northern Protestants formed the Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF) which clashed with the Irish Republic Brotherhood which had been around since the 1850s. Both sides started smuggling in weapons from abroad and in 1912 250,000 people in Ulster signed the Solemn League and Convent opposing Home Rule, (the Solemn League and Convent was a Puritanical group from the English Civil War so they decided to use history for their cause). In 1914 Unionists even bought guns from Germany saying 'If Protestant Georgie won't then Protestant Willie will'. This meant if King George would not intervene then the German Kaiser Wilhelm II would. In 1914 Home Rule was passed but implementation would be postponed. Through a complex alliance system the UK had been drawn into a European war against Germany and Austro-Hungary. The government expecting a short war and hoped the war would create a bond in Ireland. Redmond also thought this and called for the Volunteers to enlist. Out of the 210,000 Irish who went to war 24,000 of them were Volunteer members. In 1914 there were 190,000 members of the Volunteers and 150,000 had supported the war. As the war proved to be longer than expected the calls for Home Rule or even independence started to grow.

The Leaders of the Uprising
http://www.longfordatwar.ie/1916-rising/general-information
 The Easter Rising was partially planned by seven people (left to right): Thomas MacDonagh, Joseph Mary Plunkett, Seán MacDiarmada, Thomas Clarke, James Connolly, Eamonn Ceannt and Patrick Pearse. When the rising took place there was around fifteen key figures. Countess Markievicz would also play a massive role becoming the unofficial female leader of the rising. All of these men had Irish ancestry although many were not born in Ireland. I live in Edinburgh and are quite close to where one of the leaders were actually born; James Connolly was born on the street of Cowgate in Edinburgh's Old Town. All the leaders were associated with militant organizations; mostly with the Irish Republican Brotherhood and Volunteers although Connolly was associated with the socialist Citizen Army. Each had different backgrounds as well: Patrick Pearse was a poet and barrister, Sean McDiarmada had a long association with nationalist groups, Markievicz was a suffragette and socialist, Thomas Clarke was another revolutionary leader who's father had been a sergeant in South Africa and James Connolly had been a socialist activist. They were drawn together due to their connections in nationalist groups and their wanting for an independent Irish republic. Not all nationalists had wanted Home Rule as Redmond and Parnell had wanted. Many wanted an independent, Gaelic Irish republic.

The planners wanted to this Ireland and decided to orchestrate a popular rising with a twist. This rising would not be an Irish equivalent of the Battle of Lexington and Concord or one of Toussaint L'Ouverture's spectacular battles in the Haitian Revolution. They knew that they would fail and they knew that they would die. A rising would be classed as treason and during the war they knew that they would be executed. However, they wanted to inspire the Irish people. Catholics and Protestants would fight together and be executed together to create a feeling of unity and, revitalize the campaign for independence. This appealed much to the poet Patrick Pearse who spoke often of a romanticized 'blood sacrifice'. They decided that the uprising should take place largely in Dublin, they knew that if it happened in Belfast it would descend quickly into sectarian violence, and that there should be smaller risings in surrounding areas. Thomas Clarke wanted to get international support by having feelers sent to the USA for support and to India in the hope that Indian nationalists could simultaneously rise. Both of these ideas did not work. One of the leaders, Roger Casement, in 1915 though went to Germany for support. Although he failed to get Irish POWs to support him he did managed to get the support of the German military who supplied him with guns. However, the British navy intercepted the ship and Casement was tried and executed in 1916. Finally the group planned who would rise; the Irish Republican Brotherhood, Irish Volunteers, Irish Citizen Army (Connolly's socialists) and the Cumann na mBan (a nationalist paramilitary group for women). 

The Rising
http://www.irishcentral.com/news/dublin-still-bears-the-scars-of-the-1916-easter-rising-almost-100-years-later-170010346-237576791.html
 Initially planned for Easter Sunday it was moved to Easter Monday instead (which caused much confusion for some people who planned to join in but could not in the end). On Easter Monday, April 24 1916, 1200 members of the Volunteers, Citizen Army and Cumann na mBan seized key buildings in Dublin. The General Post Office (GPO) was seized and became the base for the leaders. Shortly after the Irish flag was raised over the GPO and, a Proclamation of the Irish Republic was read out and signed by the seven earlier mentioned. At the time it was one of the most liberal documents proclaiming equality of the sexes, promising to end social injustice, ending sectarianism, equality in the eyes of the law and securing citizen rights. In the early hours of the rising many of the 1200 learnt that this would be their only battle but fought on anyway. Some thought it was better to fight and die than not fight at all. Others saw the conviction of the leaders and became convinced. There are many accounts in the Irish Military Archives which has first hand accounts of those who met the leaders and saw their conviction. Pearse for example has been noted as being very convicted and when asked about the chances of success Connolly simply said 'none whatever'. Among those who took part in the rising included one of the architects of Ireland's independence Michael Collins and the future Irish President Eamon de Valera.

Many women took part in the rising thanks to Cumann na mBan. Pearse actually said: The Irish Republic is entitled to, and hereby claims, the allegiance of every Irishman and Irishwoman. The Republic guarantees religious and civil liberty, equal rights and equal opportunities to all its citizens, and declares its resolve to pursue the happiness and prosperity of the whole nation and of all its parts, cherishing all the children of the nation equally… Countess Markievicz was a suffragette and a socialist who has often been overlooked when talking about leaders of the rising. Both a Protestant and a woman she perfectly emphasized that the risers wanted a united, equal Ireland. Markievicz was responsible for setting up barricades in Dublin and, was responsible for shooting an unarmed Dublin police officer (which killed him) and a British army sniper (who survived). Rose McNamara led a battalion comprising of only women and was one of the last people to surrender. In fact the last three occupying the GPO were three women: Winnie Carney, Elizabeth O'Farrell and Julia Grenan. However, during the rising often the egalitarian Proclamation was ignored and women were forced to act as nurses or cooks while men did the fighting, this happened at the GPO. Also Eamon de Valera ignored direct orders from Pearse and Connolly to allow women fighters in his area.

In the end the rising was crushed, as they had expected. The risers had little public support as they had disrupted life in Dublin. Many mothers got money from the government to live off of when their husbands were at war. They got the money from the GPO which was unavailable to them now. Also the risers would shoot looters earning them fewer friends. John Maxwell, the person sent by the British army to stop the rising, was extremely brutal. He viewed the risers as dishonorable by rising up during a war and, he believed many rumors of the risers using human shields (possibly untrue). His brutal repression was at the time, and today, was compared to the repression that the British army had done in the colonies. This caused many in Ireland to question their place in the UK: how could they be British citizens if this level of brutality was enacted on them by Westminster? When the fighting had stopped on April 29 66 risers were killed and 143 police and soldiers were killed. However, around 260 civilians had been killed over five days.

Aftermath
Dublin's Four Courts bombed in the Civil War: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Dublin
The seven signers of the Proclamation and nine other key figures were executed. These included Connolly and Pearse. Countess Markievicz was almost sentenced to death but was let off because she was a woman. Eamon de Valera was also going to be sentenced to death but was instead incarcerated due to his American citizenship. Ninety others were sentenced but soon were incarcerated instead when the government was fearful of creating martyrs. There is little evidence that the rising directly created martyrs but it did create much sympathy for those in the south. The Unionist, British press and politicians accused a republican party, Sinn Fein, of causing the rising and arrested many members including its leader Arthur Griffith. This alongside 3500 men and 80 women being sent to Fron-goch Camp in Wales and arbitrary arrests drew more support to republicanism. The arrest of Sinn Fein's leaders caused the party to adopt a support for armed militancy. In 1917 the passing of the Conscription Act in Ireland caused outrage. This, the treatment of the risers and the arbitrary arrests caused a shift in the south from supporting Home Rule to supporting republicanism. In 1917 Michael Collins helped form the Irish Republican Army and when the arrested were released Eamon de Valera was elected as Sinn Fein's leader. In the 1918 election Sinn Fein won 73 out of 105 Irish seats but instead of sitting in Westminster on January 21 1919 they formed their own Parliament, the Dail, in Dublin. Thus started the Irish War of Independence. 

Westminster sent armed veterans called the Black and Tans and the Auxiliaries in 1920 who started committing various atrocities. In 1920 they basically burnt down Cork city and following the IRA executing fourteen spies while they slept the Auxiliaries shot at a crowd watching a football match associated with the Gaelic Athletic Association. In 1921 various Irish politicians and the British government realized tit-for-tat killings by the IRA and Black and Tans/Auxiliaries were making matters worse. They decided to create an Irish Free State in the southern Catholic provinces while leaving the largely Protestant Ulster in British hands. De Valera opposed this and the Irish Civil War broke out between Pro-Treaty forces (who accepted the split) and Anti-Treaty forces (who opposed the split). After almost a year of fighting the Pro-Treaty forces won. Ulster instead would get Home Rule and a parliament was established in Stormont. However, what the Irish Free State and Northern Ireland governments were like was nothing similar to what the Proclamation of the Irish Republic had claimed. In 1937 the Free State became a Republic while the north saw years of sectarian violence and a removal of a parliament in 1972. Today the Republic is one of the most egalitarian and democratic countries in the world while Northern Ireland has a power-sharing Assembly slowly working to end sectarianism.

Legacy
https://www.geni.com/projects/1916-Easter-Rising-in-Ireland/17385
The legacy of the Rising has shifted, as with many historical events, over the years. In 1926 with the ten year anniversary in the Free State celebrated the Rising as the birth of Ireland. The Rising was seen as their equivalent of the Battle of Bunker Hill where Irish blood forged an Irish nation. In 1946 this image changed again. The world had just gone through the trauma of the Second World War and democracies (for western Europe and Japan that is) had triumphed over dictatorships and fascism. The Rising was then seen as a battle for democracy and equality. With the Proclamation this was easy to claim. The Risers were fighting to end sectarianism and bring equality for all of Ireland. During the Troubles in Northern Ireland the Rising changed from being seen in a positive light to being something to be ashamed of. With sectarian violence in the north the violence during the Rising was linked to it. In the north at the time the Rising was seen by the more vocal nationalists as being something that should be celebrated and had to be continued whereas unionists saw it as something bad. The Cranberries song Zombie perfectly shows this view. The band came from the Republic and their song was about the IRA killing some children in a bomb blast. In 2016 the rising's legacy is not clear. Both Ireland and the UK have worked together to create events commemorating the Rising. In Ireland several documentaries and docu-dramas have been released to mark the centenary. Some have faced criticism because the audience disagreed with what was said in the programs. One hundred years on the Easter Rising still means very different things for different people. It is really up to the individual to decide what the Rising means to them.

The sources I have used are as follows:
-Ireland 1798-1998 by Alvin Jackson
-The Two Irelands 1912-1939 by David Fitzpatrick
-Modern Ireland 1600-1972 by Robert Foster
- The lectures of Doctor Jeremy Crang and Doctor Niall Whelehan of the University of Edinburgh

Saturday, 16 April 2016

Comics Explained: Doctor Strange

http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Stephen_Strange_(Earth-616)
Earlier this week the trailer for Doctor Strange starring Benedict Cumberbatch was released. Dr Strange is a prominent but not well known member of the Marvel universe. Since his debut in 1963 he has battled the forces of evil either by himself or, with other heroes, such as the Avengers. Today we'll look more closely at the Sorcerer Supreme.

Origin
http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Stephen_Strange_(Earth-616)
Dr Strange would make his debut in Strange Tales #110 but it would take until issue 115 for his origin to be revealed. Stephen Strange was a very successful but arrogant surgeon. That is until he was in a serious car accident. He managed to survive but the nerves in his hands were badly damaged which meant that he could not continue as a surgeon or, even as a consultant or an assistant. Strange would travel all over following rumors about cures which left him destitute. He started depending on alcoholism and, to pay off his bar tabs and quests for cures he began performing back alley surgeries which would later come back to haunt him. Eventually he heard about someone called the Ancient One living in the Tibetan mountains who could potentially fix his hands. Using what remained of his money he traveled to the Ancient One's temple. The Ancient One, however, refused to fix Strange's hands; instead he offered Strange the opportunity to learn magic and become his apprentice. Strange initially refused as he did not believe in magic. However, before he left he saw the Ancient One's apprentice, Baron Mordo, secretly summon skeletons to attack the Ancient One. Mordo then cast a spell on Strange which prevented him from telling the Ancient One about what he saw as well as stopping him from physically harming Mordo. He realized the only way to stop Mordo was to train under the Ancient One and eventually become his successor. The Ancient One started training Strange and removed the restraints on him (he knew that Mordo was treacherous but kept him around to control/reform him). Over several years Strange learnt the ways of magic and learnt how to use the power of powerful magical beings, such as Dormammu and the Vishanti, who he would later battle against. When Strange passed his final test he was given an ageless life (which allowed the Ancient One to live for over 600 years) and became the new Sorcerer Supreme. After travelling the world meeting other mystics he created a home called the Sanctum Sanctorum in Greenwich Village, New York.

Adventures
Strange v Dormammu: http://comicvine.gamespot.com/dormammu/4005-2205/
Alongside his servant and friend Wong Dr Strange would fight users of dark magic in order to save the world. Quite often this would lead him to mystical, surreal dimensions (his creator Steve Ditko would be inspired by a mixture of Salvador Dali, pulp-magazines of his childhood and the contemporary Beat culture). In 1968 he would so popular as a character, perhaps due to the surrealist images being popular with the counterculture of the 1960s, that Strange Tales would be renamed Doctor Strange just for him. Dr Strange would remain aloof from heroes such as the Fantastic Four choosing instead to battle figures like Baron Mordo alone. That is until he was tricked by Loki into attacking Thor. Strange soon learnt of the trickery and aided Thor in defeating Loki. From then on he would ally himself with more heroes. For example, when Baron Mordo trapped several people in a mystical realm he teamed up with a young Spider-Man to help save them. This eventually led them to become close friends. In Marvel Feature #1, released 1971, faced with an invasion by the Undying Ones (a Lovecraftian like race of demons who once ruled Earth) he formed the Defenders with the king of Atlantis Namor and the Hulk. The group continued with Silver Surfer quickly joining the roster and over the years the group would go through many members including Hellcat, Luke Cage and Valkyrie. However, in 1964 he would face for the first time one of his most persistent enemies and one of Marvel's greatest villains: Dormammu.

Dormammu
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dormammu
Dormammu first appeared in Strange Tales #126 in 1964. Dormammu ruled over the Dark Dimension and wished to conquer the realm that Earth inhabited but had been thwarted by the Ancient One. It was on Dormammu's orders that Baron Mordo had plotted to overthrow the Ancient One. While Dr Strange was acting as Sorcerer Supreme Dormammu detected that the Ancient One's health was failing. Seeing this as his chance to invade he invited Strange to the Dark Dimension for a magical duel. If Strange fell and with the Ancient One growing ill no one would be able to oppose him. However, a mystic named Clea, (who was his sister's daughter), wanted to prevent the duel as she knew that if Dormammu won Earth would be destroyed but, if Dormammu lost his fall would weaken the dimensional boundaries which would allow the Dark Dimension to be ravaged by the Mindless Ones, (unstoppable magical killing machines). The duel happened regardless and Strange was defeated (but not killed). However, Dormammu's victory had depleted his energy which allowed the Mindless Ones to break into the Dark Dimension. Wanting to save the inhabitants of the Dark Dimension Dr Strange gave Dormammu some of his power in return for sparing Earth's realm and Clea. Reluctantly Dormammu accepted but vowed vengeance on Strange.
Clea http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Clea_(Earth-616)

Clea would enhance her powers under the tutelage of Strange. Eventually she would become a mystic as powerful as he was. Simultaneously Clea and Strange fell in love. Together they would fight evil as part of the Defenders becoming integral members of the team. Eventually though they fell apart and Clea returned to the Dark Dimension to oust her mother who had taken the throne following the disappearance of Dormammu. She managed to rekindle her relationship with Strange when she became the queen of the Dark Dimension where they even married. However, Dormammu and her mother eventually returned forcing Clea to become the leader of a resistance. Since then she has balanced her time leading the resistance against Dormammu and aiding the Defenders.

2000s
http://marvel.wikia.com/wiki/Stephen_Strange_(Earth-616)
During the Kree-Skrull War Dr Strange alongside Iron Man, Professor X, Mr Fantastic, Namor and, Black Bolt formed the Illuminati to share information in order to safeguard the planet. This ended up resulting in the exile of the Hulk to the planet Sakaar (and the Hulk's furious retaliation during the World War Hulk storyline) as well as a covert Skrull invasion of Earth. The Illuminati had visited the Skrull homeworld to warn them against invading Earth but this led to their brief capture. During that time the Skrulls took DNA from them which was later used for them to accurately blend in with humans. During the Civil War storyline he opposed the Superhero Registration Act in an Illuminati meeting but went into exile in the Arctic as if he had taken sides it would have influenced the evolution of superhumans in society which went against his role as Sorcerer Supreme. Following the end of the Civil War he was given immunity but he chose to harbor heroes who refused to register. When the Skrulls finally invaded the Sanctum Sanctorum was invaded by a servant of Dormammu called the Hood and the battle against the Hood (and the Hood's lackeys) caused Strange to use dark magic to repel them. This caused him to reject the mantle of Sorcerer Supreme and search for a new Sorcerer Supreme to replace him. Brother Voodoo was chosen by a mystical item called the Eye of Agamotto and the spirit of the Ancient One. When Brother Voodoo (who had changed his name to Doctor Voodoo) sacrificed himself to destroy Agamotto Strange was given back his role as Sorcerer Supreme. Since then Dr Strange has been the Sorcerer Supreme. 

Thanks for reading and please leave any suggestions for a future Comics Explained. 

Friday, 8 April 2016

What If: Godzilla Was Real?

http://www.thefocuspull.com/features/gojira-japanese-original/
This post will be the 100th post on this blog! To celebrate I'm remaking my second alternate history scenario. I am a massive fan of the Godzilla movies and this original scenario was released to coincide with the 2014 remake of the series. Godzilla has been one of the most endearing movie characters appearing in over twenty films, having a star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame and, having two remakes to his name (a bad one be Roland Emmerich and a good one by Gareth Edwards). With a new film being released this year in Japan by Toho it is more fitting to revise what the world would be like if he existed. The existence of a giant monster (kaiju) in real life would fundamentally change world history and Godzilla would seriously change the course of history if he existed. Although Godzilla could not exist in real life, (this very good VSauce video explains why: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3cesaPTik_Q), we'll overlook this issue and do two scenarios: one following the Toho films and one following the 2014 film.

The King of Monsters Rises
http://manapop.com/film/retrospective-review-gojira-1954/
The first Godzilla movie was released in 1954; the world was gripped in the fear of total nuclear war between the United States and Soviet Union, the occupation of Japan had mostly ended and, the economies of Japan and the United States were booming. Japan is peaceful until one day one of the Bonin Islands is attacked by a 50 meter tall creature. The world press soon learn of the existence of the kaiju Godzilla: a giant dinosaur which can breathe fire as well as leaving a trail of destruction and radioactivity in its wake. Soon Godzilla attacks Tokyo completely destroying it. The Japanese Self-Defense Force is powerless to fight the kaiju and it is only stopped when scientist, Daisuke Serizawa, sacrifices himself to kill the creature with a new weapon called the 'Oxygen Destroyer'. 

Following Godzilla's rampage Japan is devastated. Most of Tokyo is destroyed and the area, as well as the surrounding area, is bathed in radiation. One scene in the film shows fish dying from the residue of Godzilla's radiation so we can assume that the same would happen in Tokyo. In 1955 Tokyo had a population of around 8,037,000 so following Godzilla's attack millions would die due to there being little time to evacuate the city. Thousands more would go on to die of radiation poisoning. Everyone who was not killed through Godzilla or his radiation would be left homeless. Japan would face a major refugee crisis with thousands fleeing inland or to one of the other islands, like Hokkaido. Some may flee abroad to the United States and Australia, especially those who had family. Hawaii and California would have a massive influx in the Japanese population. The politics and economy of Japan would collapse. With Tokyo an irradiated wasteland the capital would have to move to Osaka and the government of Shigeru Yoshida would be discredited. Far right and far left politics would flourish in the turmoil of Godzilla and, Shigeru would likely be forced to resign over it. The Post-War Economic Miracle would collapse. Many major companies like Sony and Casio were located in Tokyo so they would likely disappear thanks to Godzilla; not to mention how the withdrawal of foreign investment and high unemployment (created via refugees and collapsing companies) would place so much pressure on the economy. Finally we would see large amounts of anti-Americanism in Japan. Through US nuclear bomb testing Godzilla awoke so people would blame the US for their suffering; the USSR, China and North Korea may even use it as propaganda to criticize the US. Riots would occur on Okinawa where the United States still held military bases. In modern day Okinawa there is still large amounts of resentment to the presence of US forces on the island so following Godzilla's attack this would be greatly escalated. Clashes between Japanese citizens and US forces would exacerbate already frayed tensions. 
https://mubi.com/films/godzilla-raids-again
Just a year after Godzilla Toho released the (much weaker) Godzilla Raids Again. Here a new Godzilla emerges and fights another kaiju called Anguirus in Osaka. In this scenario just a year after Godzilla's attack a new Godzilla duels another giant monster in the new capital. Like what happened in Tokyo Osaka is destroyed. Hundreds of thousands of people are killed and many more are left as refugees. Here the world makes three realizations: the weapons that did so much damage just ten years prior are useless against kaiju, kaiju attacks are becoming common and nuclear weapons had now created three monsters. Full blown anti-American riots break out in Japan as soldiers are lynched in Okinawa, American aid workers are attacked and, stores selling US goods are vandalized. The Japanese people are angry that America's carelessness had destroyed their two largest cities, killed millions of their family members and had destroyed their economy. The Communist Party gets thousands of members among the unemployed while the (then newly formed) far-right Ishin Seito Shimpu gets just as many with ultra-nationalists driven to the edge thanks to the kaiju. Between 1955 and 1975 (the last of the Showa Godzilla films) thirteen Godzilla movies would be released as well as thirteen other kaiju films including Mothra, Rodan and Varan the Unbelievable. With the constant kaiju attacks Japan would fundamentally change. Cities near the sea like Kobe and Yamato would become deserted as people flee inland with there being a reduced chance of kaiju attack. Hawaii, Australia and California would become heavily influenced by Japanese culture due to the amount of people fleeing there. Sydney, Los Angeles and San Diego would have large numbers of Japanese citizens living there and Japanese would become an everyday language in these cities alongside English. 

As the years drag by and Godzilla (and other monsters) ravage cities more frequently the Pacific world would change. Most of Japan's economy would be devoted to the Self-Defense Force in order to fend off the monsters. Conscription for all adults for several years would be implemented early on and coastal cities such as Yamamto would become virtually military bases preparing for the inevitable attacks. Tokyo would slowly be reclaimed although food and water would have to be imported as the land (and Tokyo Bay) would still be too unsafe to take food/drink from. The coastal cities would be lightly populated with the military comprising the largest residents although there would be civilians to cater for the army like store owners and teachers for a soldier's family. Many aspects of Japanese culture now big in the west, such as anime, would never even develop never mind leave Japan. With a total war economy Nintendo, for example, would never be created so there would be no video game industry, anime got big in the 1970s so we would not see anime outside of Japan and, many domestic appliances were developed in Japan so they would not be created in this timeline. In the Heisei era films it is implied that kaiju attack cities as they are heavily populated. In real life cities cannot be instantly rebuilt as they are in the films so likely many future attacks would happen on cities on the Pacific. Due to the fact that the initial attacks only occurred on Japan these cities would be instantly taken off-guard. Darwin, Seoul, Beijing, Hong Kong and Singapore just to name a few cities would be demolished by Godzilla, Mothra and various other kaiju. Like Japan, countries bordering the Pacific would spend millions turning coastal areas into defensive areas against giant monsters. Richer countries like China and the US would build coastal walls to prevent monsters ravaging their lands. Military technology, however, would become something equivalent to that of a sci-fi movie, almost like the film Pacific Rim, as the world realizes they have to upgrade warfare as tanks and planes prove ineffective against kaiju. Inevitably wars between countries would become ever more devastating. However, as nuclear weapons had created the monsters and proved to be effective the campaigns against nukes would be universally supported. In 1998 Roland Emmerich created an abysmal remake of the King of Monsters but, in a Toho movie (Godzilla, Mothra, King Ghidorah: Giant Monsters All-Out Attack) made a reference to that film. That means in this scenario there is a monster attack in the Atlantic and New York is devastated. The world then realizes: nowhere is safe from kaiju.

2014 Godzilla
http://cinefantastiqueonline.com/2014/05/godzilla-2014-review/
In this new scenario Godzilla awakens to battle the two MUTO where the 1954 attack never happened. Like in the film the three kaiju battle leaving Las Vegas, Honolulu and Los Angeles devastated in their wake. Following the battle America would be in crisis. Los Angeles, Las Vegas and Honolulu have a combined population of 19,528,146 people and we can assume all three cities were devastated thanks to the MUTOs and Godzilla. A good few million of this number would manage to make it out okay as Los Angeles was mostly evacuated. However, Honolulu and Las Vegas received no warning so it is likely that there was a high casualty rate. Worse case scenario and only a quarter of this number survived that means around 4,882,036 would be displaced. North Korea would use the kaiju rampage as propaganda hailing it is a great victory against the United States. The economy would be seriously hit. All three cities offer huge revenue in regards to tourism but, the loss of Los Angeles would be especially hard on the USA. Many major companies are located in Los Angeles, such as 20th Century Fox, so the stock in these companies would plummet. Naturally unemployment would skyrocket and billions would have to be paid to rebuilt what was destroyed. Unlike the last scenario Godzilla did not emit radiation in the 2014 film so rebuilding Los Angeles, Las Vegas and Honolulu would be an easier task (although still extremely costly). Sanitation, rubble clearing, road surfacing and fire control would be the main tasks although in Las Vegas and Honolulu the job would be harder. Honolulu was flooded by a tsunami created by Godzilla surfacing and Las Vegas is in a desert where the nearest water source is many miles away. Rebuilding could take generations but the immense loss of life (through displacement or death) would leave a toll on the cities. Nuclear issues, however, would be a much less controversial case. In the UK General Election in 2015 there were intense debates about whether to keep the UK's Trident program (the UK's nuclear weapon program). In the light of nuclear weapons attracting the MUTO and awakening Godzilla the general consensus would be they have to go. World populations would be fearful if the nuclear weapons of their countries would attract other kaiju. Three had appeared virtually out of nowhere so the feeling would be that there could be many more. The campaign for nuclear disarmament would get a new lease of life.

Thanks for reading and staying with me over 100 posts! Did you like the two alternate history scenarios? Please leave any comments.